I spent much of my time with Nashville based horror The Other People frustratingly confused. I just could not work out what was going on in this very weird and very bleak Chad McClarnon directed and co-written movie (co-written with brother Trey McClarnon). Ultimately, this sure did leave an impression, and with a nights rest between watching it, I have started to piece things together in my mind. I will try and avoid spoilers were possible as this really isn't what it at first seems.
After the death of his wife, William Marsh (Bryce Johnson - Terrifier 3, Oppenheimer) moves to a new town with his young daughter - Abby (Valentina Lucido - iCarly) to begin a new life. At the college where he has been posted to, he encounters dance instructor; Rachel (Lyndie Greenwood - Sleepy Hollow). Fast forward to Abby's eighth year birthday and the two are now married and living together. Abby has recently gotten an apparent imaginary friend, someone she refers to as Eric (Braydon Mohr). Logical William isn't happy with this development, but Rachel sees it as a normal part of growing up, especially with the child being in a new town where she doesn't know anyone. As well as this friend, Abby also has frequent apparent nightmares in which she says a scary man (Hank Quillen - The Nice Guys) tries to abduct her in her bedroom. Are these strange things all coming from a young child's imagination, or is something more sinister at play?
I can't recall the last time I saw a movie as miserable as this one. There are some scenes here that even I found genuinely shocking to see play out; a mid-film flashpoint in particular was so bleak and cruel that for around ten minutes after it happened I assumed I had been mistaken! There are some scenes of strong violence and horror that take place often without really showing anything graphic on screen. The gist of what is happening felt visceral regardless, proving that often the viewers imagination really can fill in the blanks much better than anything that could have been shown to them.
I figured this was a supernatural movie, figuring the imaginary friend and nightmare man were both in fact ghosts. This ghosts are approached in a different way to usual. They look human for one thing even if they do appear to appear and disappear at will. These ghosts also seem to have needs, stealing food and other items from the family, something which sets Rachel on a path of suspicion that something untoward is happening in the house. Initially, I finished the film not really knowing what had gone on, but thinking about it now, it had similarities to Us, the story a commentary on American society, done in a bit of a more grounded way. Some of the ghosts resemblance to the protagonists led to some bewildering scenes that were really hard to parse. Things such as a character seemingly being in two places at once, another time when I had thought a ghost (excellently played by Liz Atwater) was one of the main characters so couldn't understand why she was in the scene she was in and acting so strangely.
The protagonists were hard characters to get a decent idea of. William was still grieving the death of his first wife, but it was never really explained that well. It led to random scenes of him crying where I was unsure what the matter was with him. Rachel was a more interesting character, taking to the role of step-mother as best as she could. While she did appear to love William, there were odd scenes when it felt like there was a gap of resentment between the two, giving the feel of missing scenes where they had fallen out with each other. I did like a lot of the minor cast members, maybe the grumpy stereotypical detective (B.D Boudreaux) being my favourite of these. He played a stereotypical detective role sure, but he brought life to it even so. The odd next door neighbour was also a memorable character, the film's one attempt at vaguely alluding to what was actually going on.
There is a purposely off vibe, especially with the night time sequences that take on the feel of a living dream. I'm sure all these similarities between the living and the 'others' was intentional, but on a first viewing it left me often scratching my head in confusion, rather than being immersed in the story. As frustrated as I became, there were some legitimate neat scenes of horror, often with the 'others' hidden in plain sight in the background of shots. There was also some full frontal nudity, something I'm not usually keen on as just seems like needless titillation. Here though, it just about gets a pass within the context of the scenes it is used in.
Some elements of the plot seemed needless, in particular a subplot revolving around William's young assistant, Emily (Quinnlan Ashe), maybe meant to be a red herring, but this sub plot fizzled out and led to nothing of note whatsoever, making me wonder why it was included in the first place. By making the actual plot murky, it did lead to feelings of alienation. It must have done something right though, being tired, I had intended to only watch half the film last night. Instead I found myself unable to stop watching, captivated by the strange two hour film.
The Other People isn't a feel good movie at all, and it can be abrasive with how it tells its story. It did turn into something far different to the generic ghost story I figured it would be; something just as outlandish, but done in an effectively creepy way. I can't say I enjoyed the film, but it was striking and it was memorable. The Other People premiered at Cinequest, screened at FrightFest and Fantaspoa, and was named in the 2026 Popcorn List as one of the best films from the festival circuit. The film has been acquired by The Horror Collective; the genre label of Studio Dome.
SCORE:
No comments:
Post a Comment